Written by:
Our November Chat, Co-designing Place-based Networks, was co-hosted with Paul Crozier of the Holborn Community Association. Together, we were interested in exploring networks that bring together local people, groups and organisations to help support vital dialogue and collaborative action to improve our neighbourhoods, villages, towns and cities. In particular, we were keen to consider place-based networks as a means of enabling and enhancing community power. We were joined by a range of participants from diverse communities, sectors and areas of practice, which allowed us to look at our theme from a variety of angles and experiences.
Key Themes
Paul kicked off our conversation with examples from the work of Holborn Community Association and its focus on community power, health and wellbeing. Some of our participants were also convenors of networks and engagement activities, and one of the clear themes that emerged was the importance of investing in relationships and dialogue over time. This led to a discussion about the activation and exchange of different types of knowledge and expertise and how we share what we have learnt. We also considered the difference between engagement on specific schemes and policies and a broader, more strategic place-based dialogue, as well as the role that community based organisations and networks can play in supporting that more continuous exchange.
Investing in Relationships and Dialogue Over Time
One of the recurring themes across our Chats is the importance of investing in ongoing dialogue and building relationships when shaping and stewarding places. Our theme of place-based networks gave us a lens through which to explore what that might look like in practice. Paul’s examples of the conversations that were happening locally illustrated the value of dialogue on broad themes, such as health and wellbeing, to help identify, address and respond to very specific local issues and opportunities. For example, one such conversation has led to local organisations exploring together how they can make their spaces available in moments of crisis or emergency, or simply as a refuge from extreme temperatures for local people.
Local conversations are also hugely important to informing national policy and practice, as noted by a participant who works at a national body promoting research, excellence and policy. He spoke of the importance of conversations with people at a local level to understand the breadth of communities’ experiences of a particular issue, such as flooding. As he put it, “It’s essential that we expose decision-makers to the realities of the sharp end of what it’s like to live in different places.”
Place-based networks could be extremely useful to such work because they create a framework for tapping into existing local dialogues, rather than having to create new engagement strategies every time someone would like to access local expertise. Changing this dynamic can also help address real or perceived power imbalances. Who convenes a conversation, how they convene it and how it informs decision-making can have a huge impact on the diversity of voices involved. It also influences the level of trust with which people engage. Place-based networks could also help tackle the considerable frustration at the sheer number of community engagement programmes that might be happening at any given time in any given area.
Activating Expertise Through Knowledge Exchange
This highlighted one of the tensions that many communities feel with engagement in placemaking, and indeed with academic research, which is that it can feel extractive or transactional. Many feel that consultation and engagement has become a box to tick to get through planning, or as a means of attracting research funding, and rarely creates a space for working collaboratively to identify opportunities, develop shared objectives and co-design initiatives.
We spoke about the importance of any engagement or partnership project recognising and valuing the different types of expertise, whether technical or lived experience, that is injected into a process. Place-based networks within any community can gather and harness existing expertise, and also produce new knowledge. Yet one of the frustrations that our group identified was that it is not always easy to share that learning with the decision-makers who implement change. At times, it is simply difficult to understand who is best placed to receive and use it. In other cases, community networks lack the time and resources to capture and share their learning or find that their learning is not valued as much as that produced in academia or by the public or private sectors.
As one of our group remarked, learning in place-based conversations and networks is as important as the more target-driven deliverables, but it doesn’t necessarily produce outputs that decision-makers or funders understand or value.
Respecting Good Practice that Exists in Communities
This led to an interesting discussion about good practice and who is best placed to convene and maintain place-based dialogue over time, as well as how this might be resourced. Place-based networks, conversations and collaborations are already happening to varying degrees around the country. However, we must also recognise that sadly, there is little investment or resourcing of time and money for enduring place-based conversations and networks.
Community and voluntary sector organisations, and in particular those operating at a local level, are extremely well placed to convene and manage local dialogue in most places. However, too often they are seen by the public, private and higher education sectors as merely gatekeepers to specific interest groups within communities, rather than as skilled practitioners whose practice is rooted in local knowledge and empowering the people and places around them. This is not to say that the public, private and education sectors cannot also convene useful place-based conversations, but that there is potential to achieve so much more if the different sectors work together to shape, resource, maintain and learn from localised place-based networks.
Wrapping Up
Too often, the conversations that we have about our places are linked to specific projects and consultations and tend to focus on issues or opportunities that have already been established. However, place, and our interaction with it, is constantly changing and evolving, as are all of us. Place based-networks perhaps offer us the opportunity for dialogue to change and evolve with our places, and vice versa. These networks will inevitably be stronger and more productive if they bring together and benefit from diverse voices and expertise and activate reciprocal exchange, collaboration and learning.
Spotlight Approach from Co-host Paul Crozier

Community Heath Impact Assessments
This light-touch approach from Centric Lab is designed to support community leaders work with speed to capture key insights about community health and the impacts that a policy, plan, or project may have.
Find out more and access A Community Leaders Health Impact Assessment Workbook here.